No Reply

I have spent an extraordinary amount of my life giving language to people who left me with none.

That is perhaps the strangest thing about silence. It makes a writer out of the person abandoned inside it.

You start supplying dialogue.

Maybe they are afraid.
Maybe they are overwhelmed.
Maybe they do not know how to say what they feel.
Maybe they need time.
Maybe I was too much.
Maybe I was too honest.
Maybe I should have known better.

Silence is generous that way. It gives you endless material.

What it does not give you is an answer.

And I fucking hate it.

I hate silence more than anger.

Tell me off. Tell me I misunderstood everything. Tell me you cannot give me what I want. Tell me I was foolish. Slam the door if you must.

At least a slammed door makes a sound.

Silence asks me to stand in the doorway indefinitely, wondering whether anyone is coming back.

That is its particular cruelty.

It does not wound cleanly.

It leaves the wound open and then hands you the instruments.

Here.

You figure it out.

So I do.

I become therapist, translator, investigator, defense attorney. I build entire psychological profiles for people who could have saved me the trouble with one honest sentence.

I consider their fears. Their histories. Their obligations. Their complicated lives.

I become extraordinarily compassionate toward the person who has left me sitting alone with the question.

And perhaps that is the most exhausting part.

Not the silence itself.

The work I do around it.

The excuses I manufacture. The mercy I extend. The language I lend to someone who has offered me none.

There is a peculiar humiliation in sincerity that is not met.

You say something real. Something that has come from that private place in the body where truth lives before language finds it.

And then you wait.

There should be a word for that interval.

The small eternity between vulnerability and response.

Because that is where the mind becomes dangerous.

You begin editing yourself. You begin regretting your own sincerity. You begin wondering whether you should have been quieter, cooler, less available, less fucking human.

And this is what silence does that almost nothing else can do:

it makes you suspicious of your own heart.

I do not give people silence easily.

Not because I believe everyone experiences it the way I do. I know better than that.

Some people can receive silence and keep living.

They eat dinner. They sleep. They forget to check their phones. They move through their day with astonishing competence while somewhere else another human being is reconstructing an entire conversation from debris.

I envy that sometimes.

The ability not to vibrate with absence.

Because for me, silence has never been empty.

It has weight. It changes the temperature. It sits down beside me. It follows me into the kitchen. It rides in the passenger seat.

It lies down when I do and seems to have nowhere else to be.

Maybe this is why I answer people.

Even when the answer is uncomfortable. Even when I am angry. Even when I would rather disappear.

Because I know what unanswered things can become inside a person.

Give a frightened mind silence and it will write a tragedy.

It will cast itself as the villain. It will revise the past. It will predict the ending.

And then it will sit itself down like a therapist and ask:

Why does this bother you so much?

I know every reasonable answer.

I know that people become quiet when they are afraid. I know some people need time. I know avoidance is sometimes about their own limits and not my worth.

I know all of this.

But understanding something does not always make it hurt less.

Sometimes understanding simply means you can describe the knife perfectly while it is still inside you.

And I am tired of describing knives.

I am tired of being so fluent in other people’s limitations.

I am tired of taking absence and translating it into compassion before I have even allowed myself to call it painful.

I am not asking for eloquence.

I am not asking anyone to reach into themselves and produce a sonnet.

Say the ugly thing. Say the unfinished thing.

Say, I don’t know.

Say, I am scared.

Say, I cannot.

Say, I don’t feel the same.

Say, give me time.

Say anything true enough that I do not have to spend the night inventing your half of the conversation.

Because I have done enough of that.

I have spent enough years lending language to absence.

And maybe this is my reckoning.

Not learning how to survive silence.

I already know how to do that.

Maybe the work now is to stop rescuing it. To stop explaining it. To stop softening it into something easier to forgive.

To stop putting beautiful words into mouths that chose not to speak.

And when someone leaves me with silence,

to finally leave it exactly as they gave it to me.

Wordless.